Orthodox rabbi ordains woman; Major protests follow.

The authority of Torah will rest upon her shoulders.

It definitely is a first in Jewish history.

The first orthodox woman rabbi.

And she earned it in a way that no man ever has done. She went through all the rabbinical training for three years at Manhattan’s Drisha Institute. Then she studied with Rabbi Avi Weiss, an orthodox rabbi and head of a New York yeshiva, learning psak ( how to decide Jewish law) for an additional three years.

If anyone has ever been qualified to act as an orthodox rabbi, certainly Sara Hurwitz, age 32 and mother of three children, is. No one can dispute that.

“You have risked so much to stand behind me,” Hurwitz said to Weiss in her acceptance speech. “It is my dream that young Orthodox girls will be able to say, ‘When I grow up, I want to be a maharat and serve in the capacity of female Orthodox rabbi.’ ”

No one in the congregation of over 800 people seemed to flinch. In fact, in the weeks that followed, it appeared that Weiss had accomplished something else unprecedented: a significant challenge to Orthodox rabbinical codes that had avoided waking the lions of the Establishment. This is not how he typically conducts business. Though described by his congregants as soft-spoken and gentle, he has, over the past three decades, built a career out of confrontation. He is known for his unrelenting political activism, championing causes from Soviet Jewry to clemency for Israeli spy Jonathan Pollard. Few can keep track of the number of times he’s been arrested, threatened, and lambasted. Within the Orthodox community, Weiss has been equally disruptive, agitating for what he calls an “open Orthodoxy,” which he believes can be inclusive without breaching the tradition’s stringent parameters.

This morning’s ceremony appeared to represent a quieter radicalism—no news conferences, no protests. Perhaps, even, it was a glimpse of a new Avi Weiss: as crusading as ever, but, at 64, grown wise to the benefits of diplomacy.

Those in the congregation who knew Weiss best knew better.

Everyone present agreed that Hurwitz represented something seismic. “I think everybody was in amazement that she had achieved this,” says Reform rabbi Jacqueline Koch Ellenson, who attended a meeting. Hurwitz had put in three years of learning at Manhattan’s Drisha Institute, then repeated the course work under Weiss’s supervision, this time with an eye toward psak: being equipped to weigh in on intricate questions of Jewish law. “Sara completed everything,” Ellenson continues. “She bucked the system. So what happens next? Do you let her in?” Some were afraid that by ordaining Hurwitz, Weiss would jeopardize his synagogue’s funding; others expressed concern about the impact on “his boys,” as some refer to his students from the already-controversial yeshiva he created. But after hours of discussion, the group was largely in accord: Hurwitz should be named rabbi, or, failing that, rabba.

However, the rest of the orthodox community did not keep silent.

“These developments represent a radical and dangerous departure from Jewish tradition,” declared Agudath Israel of America, ultra-Orthodoxy’s most authoritative rabbinic body. “Any congregation with a woman in a rabbinical position of any sort cannot be considered Orthodox.” Weiss, never a favorite among the hard-liners, was accused of sabotaging his community. Steven Pruzansky, a rabbi in Teaneck, New Jersey, wrote on his popular blog, “Those who seek to infiltrate the Torah with the three pillars of modern Western life—feminism, egalitarianism, and humanism—corrupt the Torah, cheapen the word of G-d.”

“There are a few who feel that ‘God has put his hand on my shoulder and said, “I need you to be an ambassador to the Jewish world,”” says Marc D. Angel, Weiss’s classmate at Yeshiva University and now rabbi emeritus of Congregation Shearith Israel on Central Park West. “Avi is one of those kinds of rabbis. He sees himself not just as a rabbi of a synagogue but as a rabbi responsible for the whole Jewish people.” In his 2008 book Spiritual Activism, Weiss wrote, “I was once involved in activism because I enjoyed it, but now I have come to believe that a true activist is one who takes no pleasure from it. Now I’m an activist because I feel I have no choice; there are things I believe I simply must do.”

[tweetmeme source=”your_twitter_name” only_single=false


Read complete article here:



About Jewish Daily Report

American patriot.
This entry was posted in American Jews, Bible, Education, Jewish, Orthodox Jews and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Orthodox rabbi ordains woman; Major protests follow.

  1. Mac-101 says:

    This is rediculous. She should have become a Rabbi in a Reformed Jewish organization. Kind makes Orthodox mean nothin. Next thing Protestants will have open Adulterers, Fornicators and Sodomizers as Pastors. Oh wait, that has happened!

    • shifra freewoman says:


      It is about time-no actually women ought to have been ordained thousands of years ago, but nu what’s a several thousand year wait, for something this important.

      Yeah, she could have become a reform rabbi, but she is orthodox and follows halacha and wants to be a rabbi with in her own denomination. I have nothing against reform, but their understanding of judaism is very different from the orthodox.

      And while Judiasm, like Islam, adn Christianity is chock full of sexism, I think one can easily make the case that discrimination against women ought not to be thought of as the essense of Judaism adn that jewish law ought ot evolve over time.

      There are many, orthodox rabbis who believe that jewish law can be understood to allow female rabbis.

      I think a bigger issue than the legal problem, is prejudice adn fear and custom.

      Its fascinating to me that you lump women in with “adulterers, fornicaters and sodomists”

      I guess that shows how you view us women.

      And, while i have nothing against Catholics, who do not ordain women as priests and who officially oppose homosexuality-their church has 1000’s of priests who have abused children, complete with an official coverup for decades.

      The churches that you condemn for allowing gay ministers adn preists do not have anything like the numbers of abusers as the catholic church. I’m sure it happens in those churches, but it seems to me that churches that are more relaxed about sexuality have less sexual abuse.

      Calm down, you really have nothing to fear from women rabbis, priests ministers, etc.

      I think God is rejoicing adn saying: about time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s